Cynicism is the Name of the Game in Jerusalem

By Maayan Raveh*

 

The Jerusalem Municipality and the State of Israel recently took action against the Churches in the capital. In response, the Churches closed the holiest place to Christian believers and sparked a storm in the world. The whole affair raises questions about the status and role of the Churches in Israel.

Last week, despite the embarrassing silence of the Israeli media, the Christian world was up in arms about the issue of the Church of the Holy Sepulcher and the dramatic decision to close it. This step was taken, according to the churches, in response to two moves against them.

The first step was a decision taken by the Jerusalem municipality to demand retroactive municipal tax payments on the church’s assets and to curtail their bank accounts until payment had been made. The second move was a bill led by Knesset Member Rachel Azaria to transfer to the state Church lands in various neighborhoods in Jerusalem. These lands were sold to private entrepreneurs, mainly by the Greek Orthodox Church.

In the end, the Church of the Holy Sepulcher remained closed for only three days, at the end of which the Prime Minister intervened in the crisis, leading to the freezing of municipal proceedings and the establishment of a Minister-lead team to resolve the issues.

The central motif of the whole affair was cynicism. The local Churches took advantage of their control of the holiest place in the Christian world, claiming “religious persecution and a systematic campaign against the Churches and Christian communities in Israel”, for political and economic ends; the Jerusalem Municipality made cynical use of the Christian communities and their relations with the Christian world, demanding the payment of huge property taxes, in order to put political pressure on the Finance Ministry to increase the municipality’s budget; and it can be claimed that the Greek Orthodox Patriarch made cynical use of the Christian communities to divert attention from the hot-potato issue of the sale of church lands to Israeli factions.

 

Church of the Holy Sepulcher. Photo by Anna Sulencka

From the research point of view, it seems that the Church’s position stems from the complicated status of the Christian population in Israel and the Palestinian Authority. Although the current crisis has erupted around the issue of the payment of property tax and the sale of church land, its treatment requires understanding of more fundamental issues.

The choice of Nir Barkat, the mayor of Jerusalem, to target the churches was not coincidental. It was done out of the belief that the churches would act exactly as they did – would use their connections in the West to create a diplomatic crisis with Israel that would serve his purposes.

Christians in the Middle East are often seen as hybrid beings: they see themselves as belonging to the Arab-Palestinian culture, but religiously they are part of Western culture. In Jerusalem, the situation is even more complicated since most of the ecclesiastical representation is not local, and the structures for which the Jerusalem Municipality demands municipal taxes do not serve mainly the local communities, but the pilgrims and foreign church members. However, for many Palestinian believers, this move is seen as part of the Church’s struggle over Israeli sovereignty over Jerusalem and as an expression of resistance to the occupation.

Here the central dilemma facing the local churches becomes clear – the tension between general interests and local interests. Is their job to preserve the holy places and to care for the millions of pilgrims who come to pray there, or is it their duty to serve the local Christian community? How should they allocate their resources accordingly? Should they represent the entire Christian world, or should they take a stand on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that directly affects the local Christian communities and guide them spiritually, taking into account their actual interests?

In Jerusalem, as in Jerusalem, these questions become more acute and bring us back to the issue of cynicism: do local churches take advantage of their control over the holiest place in the Christian world for local political struggle? On the other hand, is it not the right of the churches in Jerusalem in particular and the Holy Land in general to lead their flock, to advance their interests and to use their resources to represent the local communities? Is the holiness of Jerusalem supposed to prevent them from doing so?

The whole affair is marked by the inherent tension between Jews and Christians, which is intensified by Jewish control of the Christian holy sites. The Church even hinted at the use of harsh terms of persecution and dark periods. In the recent crisis, questions of control, sovereignty, state authority and religious authority, assets and capital are combined – all involving not only conflicting interests but also a not-insignificant serving of cynicism.

*This article was originally published in Hebrew under the Forum for Regional Thinking, and was translated by the Rossing Center after the author’s approval. To the full Hebrew version
Rossing Center logo

Other news and updates

Rossing Center logo
  • All
  • Annual Reports
  • News and Updates
  • Public events
  • Webinars
Medio Oriente, la sfida del dialogo ebrei-palestinesi
The challenge of Jewish-Palestinian dialogue – Tg2000

On December 5th, the Rossing Center hosted Alessandra Buzzetti, the Jerusalem correspondent for TV2000, the Italian broadcasting channel connected to the Vatican.

a3730f8c-732a-4ccb-2c0f-52e0bd6a468e
Lamentation from Jerusalem – 12.10.2023

These are terrible days in Israel and Palestine
Our hearts are impossibly heavy as we send our condolences to the families of the deceased, and pray for the injured and those missing and kidnapped.

The Increasing Hostility Towards Christians in the Holy Land: Voices from the Field
The Increasing Hostility Towards Christians in the Holy Land: Voices from the Field

The Increasing Hostility Towards Christians in the Holy Land: Voices from the Field In light of the disturbing increase of attacks against Christians in Jerusalem and other areas of the

unnamed-10
The Rossing Report 06/2023

Dear Friends, We write to you after months of turbulence, marked by unprecedented protests over the judicial reforms proposed by the most right-wing government in Israel’s …

צילום מסך 2023-04-30 120558
The 2022 annual report

2022 was an exciting year!
Click here to see what we’ve been up to over the past year.

331769570_777714403920423_4888398938787392095_n-1
Stories Beyond the Arches: Women’s Voices from Ramle

We are excited to invite you to the opening of the exhibition “Stories Beyond the Arches: Women’s Voices from Ramle”, which will be held on 15.3 at 18:00 in a